SHELTER ISLAND THE ULTIMATE BEACHFRONT- This brand new exquisitely built beachfront home is the perfect luxurious retreat. Enjoy panoramic bay views and your own private beachfront. Beautifully furnished with every amenity including central air conditioning,....
SHELTER ISLAND WATERFRONT HOUSE WITH DOCK PLUS LOT -This spacious waterfront home is a legal two-family, and comes with adjacent lot for a total of almost 3 acres. House features 4 bedrooms, 4.5 baths, including Master with jetted tub, living room with custom....
An opportunity to own almost 3 acres on over 200 feet of shoreline. 2 Building lots, one vacant and one with a custom designed legal 2 family residence. New deepwater dock, 2 moorings, swim spa, hot tub, sauna, freshwater pond, stone fireplace and a 2500 sq.ft....
This magnificent home is set on 1.2 acres of the former Francis Borax King Smith's estate residence and chosen for its breathtaking views of Smith's Cove and Mashomack Preserve, one of the most beautiful Shelter Island has to offer. Completely re....
Breathtaking views of Gardiner`s Bay. Spacious post and beam home with an amazing double-sided fieldstone fireplace and full wrap-around deck. Boarding over 100 feet of preserved beach.
SHELTER ISLAND-If you love water views from every room that seem to last forever, then you must see this property. Overlooking Gardiner's Bay and Mashomack Preserve, this spacious waterfront contemporary, located on sought after Big Ram, has a formal dinin....
SHELTER ISLAND-This 6 bedroom/ 4.5 bathroom classic estate with heated in-ground pool and deep-water dock has all the charm and grandeur you would expect to find in a house built circa 1860. Its rooms are filled with sunlight and there are water views from the....
This 2.94-acre Estate has all the classic details you would expect to find in a 1860 circa home. A grand foyer, parlor, full bath, formal dinning room and living room both with marble fireplaces, country kitchen, wrap around covered gazebo style porch, and a g....
SHELTER ISLAND ONE-OF-A-KIND WATERFRONT ON DERING HARBOR- A rare opportunity to own 2.5 acres on beautiful Dering Harbor. A generous 200 ft. of water frontage with a cottage affords you the opportunity for a deepwater dock and a large home with a pool and ten....
SHELTER ISLAND WATERFRONT TRADITIONAL This spacious colonial is off the beaten path – tucked into a very private waterfront cove community and a short boat ride to Peconic Bay. There are large common areas such as living room, formal dining room, kitchen....
SHELTER ISLAND-This is a new exquisite home on a quiet 1.1 acre with 3200 sq. ft. of serene living with 4 bedrooms and 3.5 bath. An open floor plan of living room, dining room and state of the art kitchen with custom cabinetry features high ceilings and Southe....
With marvelous detail throughout, including grand foyer entry, living room with soaring double height ceilings and two story fireplace, this tasteful 5 bedroom, 3.5 bath cedar shingled country home set on nearly 2 acres bordering farm and preserve, features cu....
SHELTER ISLAND OVER 12 ACRES PLUS TWO HOMES-All offers considered. Secluded family compound, hidden down a true country road. Turn of the century farmhouse with 3/4 bedrooms, 2 baths, family kitchen, great room and deck. Additional state-of-the-art country cot....
SHELTER ISLAND-Charming artist's cottage on 1.4 acres peninsula jutting into tranquil Menantic Creek. 589 ft. of waterfront with dock. Nature lovers retreat with 2 bedrooms, 1 bath, stone fireplace, detached garage and expansive deck overlooks the water.
Enjoy peaceful Shelter Island in this 4 bedroom, 4.5 bathroom house sited on 1.5 acres. Includes central air, fireplace, gourmet kitchen, granite counter tops, large family room with built-in home theater, screened-in-dining porch, wrap-around mahogany deck, h....
SHELTER ISLAND-A unique opportunity to own over 2 acres of waterfront with great privacy. Surrounded by woods, ponds and salt water marsh lands. A 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage affords vistas of Coecles Harbor, Mashomack Preserve and Little Ram Island. Your dock i....
SHELTER ISLAND-Opportunity abounds. Current uses are Automotive Repair Shop with 4 garage bays, 2 hydraulic lifts; Welding shop, and Gallery. Parking for approx 30 vehicles. Can also be subdivided for residential use. Valuable corner lot for maximum exposure. ....
SHELTER ISLAND-Opportunity abounds. Current uses are Automotive Repair Shop with 4 garage bays, 2 hydraulic lifts; Welding shop, and Gallery. Parking for approx 30 vehicles. Can also be subdivided for residential use. Valuable corner lot for maximum exposure. ....
SHELTER ISLAND-New 4BR, 3BA construction completed with an eye for detail. Chef's kitchen, spacious rooms, pool permit, private beach & tennis association membership available. Overlooks beautiful fresh water pond. $1,795,000
SHELTER ISLAND-This elegant Traditional on 1.9 acres near Gardiner’s Bay Country Club was built in 2000 with every amenity in mind. The main house contains 3 plus bedrooms with a first floor master suite. There are two additional bedrooms and a library that c....
Ward`s Point: Brand New 4 bedroom, 3.5 bath home in beautiful Shorewood Farms Neighborhood of Shelter Island.Private beach and tennis membership available.Also close to famous Wade`s Beach (Shelter Island Residents).Lovely design features a great room with fir....
SHELTER ISLAND MAGICAL VICTORIAN AUTHENTICITY-Meticulously restored and maintained. Original appointments throughout including antique footed tub. 4 bedrooms, 2 baths, gourmet kitchen, parlor with fireplace, dining room, library, loft and gallery. Secrets a....
SHELTER ISLAND-If you love attention to detail, fine craftsmanship, spacious rooms and quiet living then I encourage you to make an appointment to see this beautiful Traditional. The grand entry leads to the 2 story lving room with fireplace, chef's kitche....
SHELTER ISLAND VICTORIAN FARMHOUSE-Our 3,000 sq.ft. home has captured the old world charm of yesteryear with the sophistication and modern elegance of today. The only new construction in sought after Shorewood area, the main floor features Great room with real....
Enjoy all the luxury of quality new construction: Builder`s newly constructed home on 1 beautiful Shelter Island acre with 4 bedrooms, 2 are master suites (1 downstairs), and 3.5 fabulous and luxurious baths (white marble tops, floors, even saddles) ,beautiful....
All the beauty of a Victorian, including a center hall staircase worthy of a movie set, high ceilings, hand-crafted ornomentation and space, space space; paired with all modern amenities. A chef`s kitchen, 5 overly comfortable bedrooms, 3 1/2 baths. Within min....
SHELTER ISLAND-WATERFRONT, WOODED, PRIVACY A unique opportunity to own over 2 acres of waterfront with great privacy and a zen like quality. Surrounded by woods, ponds and salt water marsh lands. A 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage affords vistas of Coecles Harbor, M....
SHELTER ISLAND-This amazing Log Cabin home presents a rustic exterior with a luxurious interior. You will be pleasantly surprised to see state of the Art appliances, granite counters, double oven chef's stove and massive stone fireplaces plus woodburning s....
See Virtual Tour for many more photos and call Penelope Moore, exclusive listing agent at 917-208-5519 for more info! Tucked away on a private road near the Heights with views of one of the oldest farms on the Island, this modern 3 bedroom, 3 bath waterfront o....
SHELTER ISLAND RECENTLY RENOVATED AND EXPANDED- Exquisitely crafted 4 bedroom, 3.5 baths, country contemporary on 1.4 acres, with guest cottage. Located at the end of a quiet cul-de-sac, this home is in pristine, move-in condition. It features an open floor ....
SHELTER ISLAND DERING HARBOR GOLF COURSE LOT-Located at the end of a cul-de-sac on a quiet road in exclusive Dering Harbor, this wonderful 3 acre building lot borders on the Island's only private country club. Board of Health permits in place for a five bedroo....
SHELTER ISLAND NEWLY BUILT SHINGLED TRADITIONAL WITH POOL-Definitely not your average cookie-cutter spec house. This custom built traditional is well-appointed with a well thought out floor plan. Walk across the front columned porch and through the front entry....
SHELTER ISLAND-An exquisite renovated home on 1.4 acres and at the end of a very private tree lined road includes a 1BR, 1BA guest cottage. The main house offers serene living with 4BRs and 3.5BAs including two master suites. The open floor plan of Living Room....
SHELTER ISLAND-The waterfront cottage you have dreamed of. Perfect to while away the hours enjoying the views of the creek, the sunrise and the nesting birds. Great rental history. $1,200,000
SHELTER ISLAND-Truly impeccable 4BR, 4BA Traditional with 5000 sq. ft. of living space, granite kitchen with high end appliances, separate den, attached 2 car garage and private deck with family size hot tub. $1,100,000
SHELTER ISLAND BEACH COMMUNITY-Located on a private road, this state-of-the-art Colonial is in move in condition. Layout includes living room, dining room, granite kitchen, den with fireplace, 5 bedrooms and 4 baths including Master Suite. Back deck and spac....
At The End Of A Cul-De-Sac This Beautiful 4, 200 Sf Victorian Sits Elevated On A Hill With A Mahogany Wrap Around Porch, Stone Patios, Incredible Heated L Shaped Pool With A Stone Waterfall And All Can Be Seen From The Master Suite On The First Floor.It Has It....
SHELTER ISLAND RENOVATED FAMILY COMPOUND - Newly renovated, this spacious home features living room with fireplace, formal dining room, new kitchen, screened porch, recreation room, 4 bedrooms and 3 baths. Brick patio, back deck, 1 car garage, new central hea....
SHELTER ISLAND-Owner says SELL! Pool, tennis court, open floor plan with new kitchen, 4 BR, 3 Baths, hardwood floors, fireplace, finished recreation room with access to pool patio, new windows, new central air, screened in porch, circular drive. Just reduced $....
10Yr Old Custom Blt Post Modern Colonial. W. Neck Bay Waterviews. Private Beach & Mooring. Mbr Suite W / Fbth Oversize Jacuzzi, Turret, Sitting Rm W / 28Ft Deck. Open Flr Plan Kit Dr, Fr W / Massive 8Ft Stone Fpl. Sliding Drs Off Kit To 31Ft Deck. Corianne Cou....
Great location with wide open harbor views and just a short distance to pristine Shell Beach.This home has 5 bedrooms and 3 full baths. Open kitchen, living room with fireplace,enclosed porch,and the dinning room has french doors that lead out to a stone patio....
SHELTER ISLAND-Classic Colonial in the Fresh Pond area. This carefully maintained home offers 3-4BR, 2.5BAs, modern kitchen, family room, full basement, CAC, gunite pool, outdoor shower. It's perched on 11/3 acres across from preserve and in move-in condit....
SHELTER ISLAND INCOME PRODUCING PROPERTY-Recently renovated single story home features living room, kitchen, dining room, 3 bedrooms, and 2.5 baths, 2 car garage and full basement. Back deck with hot tub overlooks enclosed Victory garden and private yard. Addi....
Private Membership at Shorewood farms Beach Association, a very desirable Private Neighborhood Association at Ward`s Point on Shelter Island (with 2-acre BBay Beach Park & tennis, close to the South Ferry & Sag Harbor) is open to homeowners at Ward`s Point alo....
Just a short distance to Wades Beach And Fresh Pond, this 4 bedroom, 4 baths home has a separate 1 Bedroom, 1 Bath guest suite on the first floor. The vaulted ceiling and great open floor plan with plenty of windows make this home spacious and bright. The swim....
SHELTER ISLAND-Water views of West Neck Harbor and Shell Beach. Charming 5BR, 3BA Cape offers 1st floor BR suite, oak floors, brick fireplace, country kitchen opens to dining area that leads out to an outside stone & brick patio. Adjacent to 5 acre preserve an....
Contemporary home on a private 1/2 acre with a large cathedral ceiling, open floor plan with fireplace, and a large deck with heated gunite pool. 4 bedrooms, 2 baths and separate eat in kitchen. Private waterfront association park with beach and boating. Pe....
SHELTER ISLAND-Open and airy 4BR, 2BA contemporary with vaulted ceilings, laundry room on main level, awning covered deck overlooking the new pool. Large eat in kitchen and fireplace. Adjacent to perserved land. $795,000. Also for rent. See IN# 5405204.
SHELTER ISLAND CONTEMPORARY WITH POOL- Comfortable four bedroom, two bath contemporary. Located in quiet community with beach and boating rights, house features cathedral ceiling living room with fireplace, eat-in kitchen, dining area and den and is centrally....
SHELTER ISLAND-Brand new apartments or multi-family housing - 2 units with, 2BR, 1BA, and 1 unit with 2BR, 1.5BA. Quality built with hardwood floors, granite countertops, storage. Close to Crescent Beach, Sunset Beach Hotel and golf course. Great investment an....
SHELTER ISLAND WALK TO BEACH- Great location in waterfront community with neighboring waterfront multi million dollar homes. Walk to sandy beach and golf course. This sprawling ranch has a spacious greatroom, livingroom w/fireplace, sunny eat-in-kitchen, t....
SHELTER ISLAND - Wooded, winter water views, simply bucolic. Almost 200' of road frontage and 250' deep. New survey with health dept permit in place. Exquisite $749,000
SHELTER ISLAND SECLUDED RURAL TRADITIONAL- 1.5 acres end of cul de sac, back yard borders open space preserve. 4 bedrooms, 2.5 baths, large storage/craft room off master bedroom, office/media room, eat-in kitchen with woodstove, solid wood cabinets, wide pine ....
SHELTER ISLAND-Perfect opportunity to start a new business or create several retail store fronts in a finished ground floor 2000 sq. ft. space. On the 2nd floor are 2 spacious 2BR, 1BA ea. apartments with shared laundry facilities. Large parking area in front ....
SHELTER ISLAND VICTORIAN FARMHOUSE 1876- Walk to Sunset Beach, golf course and the Heights. Featuring 3 bedrooms, 2 full baths, marble fireplace, hardwood floors, formal dining room, quaint kitchen, living room. New covered front porch and outdoor shower. A ....
SHELTER ISLAND-Perfect opportunity to start a new business or create several store fronts in a finished ground floor 2000 sq. ft. space with 1/2 bath and large closet space. On the 2nd floor are 2 spacious 2BR, 1BA ea. apartments with shared laundry facilities....
SHELTER ISLAND OWNER WILL HELP GET THIS FINANCED- Delightful wood shingled country cottage that has been totally renovated by well known East End Builder. Quality throughout. Full basement, central air conditioning, tile baths, gourmet kitchen, hardwood floo....
SHELTER ISLAND SUNNY CONTEMPORARY WITH POOL-Impeccably maintained contemporary on 3/4 acre property with mature trees offers absolute privacy. This home features soaring ceiling in living room, a den, 3 bedrooms, 3 full baths plus finished basement with separa....
SHELTER ISLAND-Full Business zone with mixed use Certificate of Occupancy. Currently has 4BR, 2BA, Dining room, Living room with stone fireplace, hardwood floors, 1500sq. ft. of basement, perfect for storage, and large parking area. Completely renovated with c....
Full Business zone with mixed use Certificate of Occupancy. Currently has 4BR, 2BA, Dining room, Living room with stone fireplace, hardwood floors, 1500sq. ft. of basement, perfect for storage, and large parking area. Completely renovated with cedar shingle ex....
SHELTER ISLAND PRICED TO SELL- Move right in to this impeccably maintained 3 bedroom, 2 bath cottage. Renovated in 2004 with spacious Master bedroom suite with luxurious Master Bath, living room with fireplace, country kitchen, dining area with sliders to bac....
SHELTER ISLAND - Classic cottage for summer or year round living with water views. Room for expansion, guest cottage and pool. Lovely details include double farmhouse sink, renovated bath, hardwood floors, cast iron radiators. Owner motivated. $675,000
SHELTER ISLAND PRIVATE HOME WITH POOL-Down a private drive you'll find this comfortable Colonial style home. House has living room/den with raised hearth, kitchen, dining area with woodstove, five bedrooms, two full baths, and laundry room. Attached two ca....
SHELTER ISLAND-Brand new with hardwood floors, full kitchen that opens to waterside Living Room and Dining area. Two large BR's and 2 full BA's, washer/dryer and screened porch. Co-op facilities include pool, tennis courts, club house, basketball ....
SHELTER ISLAND-2 sunny cottages on 4/5's of an acre in park like setting. Newly renovated, one with 2BR and 1BA, the other with 2BR and 2BA. Walk to Sunset Beach, golf and Perlman Music Center. Perfect vacation cottages.
SHELTER ISLAND-Priced to sell! First time on the market and in move in condition. Spacious 3BR, 2BA Ranch with large back deck overlooking grassy yard with shade trees. Or cozy up to the brick fireplace in winter and enjoy the fully insulated sun room with pro....
SHELTER ISLAND BEACH & BOATING COMMUNITY- This well maintained home features 4 bedrooms 3 baths, Living room with fireplace, dining room , eat-in kitchen and den. There is a sun porch with terra cotta floors that doubles as a screened in porch for summer ente....
SHELTER ISLAND SILVER BEACH LIFE- Spacious 4 bedroom, 2 bath home with recent updates of new roof, new windows and siding. Living room with fireplace, kitchen and breakfast nook with sliders to deck. Situated on .75 acres, house comes with a waterfront beach s....
SHELTER ISLAND-Income producing property with room for pool and tennis court. Year round forever water views of Gardiner's Creek, easy to expand and priced to sell. The Ranch house is 3BR, 1BA with Dining Room, Living room with brick fireplace, eat in kitc....
SHELTER ISLAND TIDY WATERVIEW RANCH WITH GUEST COTTAGE- A well kept, turn key ranch on over 1 acre features a paneled living room with a brick wall fireplace, 3 bedrooms, pine cabinet eat-in kitchen and a dining room with a bay window, view of spacious backyar....
SHELTER ISLAND RENOVATED FARMHOUSE WITH POOL- Down a country lane, you'll find this clean and bright charming farmhouse. Layout has living room with fireplace, kitchen with gas stove, 2 bedrooms, 1.5 baths, new hardwood floors. Back deck leads to heated....
SHELTER ISLAND-A rare Arts & Crafts style home on the market. Large acerage with 4-stable horse barn, fully fenced and surrounded by preserve. Renovated in 2009 with lots of room for expansion. 2BR, 1BA, hardwood floors and rocking chair covered front porch. W....
SHELTER ISLAND STARTER OR RETIREMENT HOME- New listing! Delightful, sun-filled home in great condition. Centrally located. Beautiful grounds with room for pool. Three large bedrooms, living room with fireplace, eat-in kitchen, dining room with French doors....
SHELTER ISLAND DERING HARBOR 2 BEDROOM CO-OP-This unit is all on one level with no units above. Spacious co-op features living room with a rare fireplace, full kitchen, two bedrooms and two full baths, and a screened porch offering waterviews. Includes use o....
SHELTER ISLAND-Close to school, shopping and post office makes this large house perfect for raising a family on Shelter Island. Priced right, low taxes, 5+ bedrooms, 3 full baths, full basement, and because it is in business zone there is B&B potential. Large ....
SHELTER ISLAND - SPACIOUS CO-OP IN DERING HARBOR Enjoy care-free living in this 2-bedroom villa with full kitchen, living room with fireplace and screened-in waterview porch. Amenities include spacious grounds, pool, tennis, and dock. Maintenance includes....
SHELTER ISLAND-Full business property with cottage and detached 1 car garage. Many new updates on cottage including new electric, windows, cedar shingles and heating system. $495,000
SHELTER ISLAND-Shy treed acre in upscale waterfront community with deeded water access. Easy to build on level lot with possible water views. Exclusive $495,000
